Please note that you are using an outdated browser which is not compatible with some elements of the site. We strongly urge you to update to Edge for an optimal browsing experience.

Breaking rules in sectional title

06 Sep 2011

When you break the law, you will be fined – most of the time; rules govern society, so why not sectional title? In this article, we look at the implication of breaking rules in sectional title.

Trustees are not able to fine owners without giving them the opportunity to state their case.

The Act and the prescribed rules do not make provision for fining owners. However, many schemes do make rules that apparently entitle the trustees or a nominated third party to fine owners when they are in breach of the rules. Whether or not these fining rules are enforceable will be dependent on the specific wording of each rule; and to be enforceable, the rules need to be reasonable. To be reasonable, the rules must take into account the principles of natural justice, particularly the principle of “audi alteram partem”, which means “let both sides be heard”.

What this means is that trustees are not able to fine owners without giving them the opportunity to state their case and before considering the situation fairly and reasonably. The trustees are required to first call the apparent transgressor to a hearing, at which both sides must be given a chance to have their say and ask one another questions. After this, the persons nominated in the rules to decide the matter may decide whether the offence in question was in fact committed and determine a reasonable fine is justifiable in light of all the evidence.

If an owner and the trustees have a genuine dispute, either one of them may declare a dispute with the other. If the dispute is not resolved within 14 days, it must be referred to arbitration, whereupon an independent arbitrator will adjudicate the matter. - Jennifer Paddock

Jennifer Paddock is a sectional title expert. Paddocks, a specialist sectional title and HOA training firm, has launched   Paddocks Club   – an online community where you can ask for advice and support on your sectional title issues.

Readers' CommentsHave a comment about this article? Email us now.  

About the Author
Jennifer Paddock

Jennifer Paddock

An admitted attorney, Jennifer has specialised in sectional titles for over 6 years. She is a specialist sectional title attorney with additional experience managing strata title schemes in Victoria, Australia. Jennifer is the Managing Partner of Paddocks, a specialist sectional title training and consultancy firm as well as the Managing Director of Mystrata South Africa, providers of cloud-based sectional title property management software.

An admitted attorney, Jennifer has specialised in sectional titles for over 6 years. She is a specialist sectional title attorney with additional experience managing strata title schemes in Victoria, Australia. Jennifer is the Managing Partner of Paddocks, a specialist sectional title training and consultancy firm as well as the Managing Director of Mystrata South Africa, providers of cloud-based sectional title property management software.

Print Print
Top Articles
What sets the luxury market apart is its independence from broader economic trends and understanding what drives this market requires looking beyond the numbers to the intangibles that define true luxury.

With interest rates finally on the decline and rental vacancy rates lower than they’ve been in years, property is an excellent investment option as long as the homework is done

Holiday homes in prime destinations offer a unique opportunity to blend leisure with investment. They often appreciate due to their desirable locations and provide the potential for consistent rental returns during peak travel seasons.

Loading